THE PSYCHODYNAMIC APPROACH
SPECIFICATION: THE PSYCHODYNAMIC APPROACH
The role of the unconscious
The structure of personality, that is Id, Ego and Superego
Defence mechanisms including repression, denial and displacement, Psychosexual stages
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
PSYCHOANALYTIC PERSPECTIVE: This perspective is rooted in the original works of Sigmund Freud and encompasses theories and therapeutic methods that delve into the unconscious mind to understand and address psychological issues.
PSYCHODYNAMIC PERSPECTIVE: In contrast to the emphasis on sexuality in psychoanalysis, the psychodynamic perspective places greater importance on the role of the social environment in shaping one's personality and behaviour.
PSYCHOANALYSIS: This term refers to the therapeutic techniques and methods used within the psychoanalytic perspective. It involves exploring the unconscious mind to gain insights into a person's thoughts, feelings, and behaviours.
TRANSFERENCE: Transference occurs when individuals project emotions or feelings they have for one person onto someone else. In therapy, it can be a valuable tool for therapists to gain a deeper understanding of a patient's experiences and emotions.
COUNTER-TRANSFERENCE: Counter-transference refers to the therapist's emotional reactions and attitudes toward the patient. It includes the therapist's responses to the patient's transference, personal experiences that may impact their understanding of the patient and emotional reactions towards the patient.
PARAPRAXIS (FREUDIAN SLIP): Also known as a Freudian slip, a parapraxis is a mistake or error, such as a slip of the tongue or forgetting someone's name, that reveals an unconscious desire, thought, or conflict.
FANTASY: A fantasy is an imagined scenario that expresses an individual's desires or aspirations. It can be conscious, such as daydreaming, or unconscious, referred to as "phantasy."
RESISTANCE: Resistance in psychoanalysis refers to a patient's unconscious opposition to the exploration and revelation of painful memories during therapy. It can manifest through various mental processes, fantasies, memories, character defences, and behaviours. Importantly, it may persist even after the patient becomes consciously aware of it.
CONFRONTATION: Confrontation in therapy involves encouraging patients to face and address experiences or emotions they have been avoiding. It is a therapeutic technique aimed at facilitating personal growth and self-awareness.
GRATIFICATION: Gratification denotes the experience of pleasure or satisfaction, whether it pertains to sexual pleasure, the satisfaction of basic needs like food and warmth, or other sources of contentment.
INSTANT GRATIFICATION: This term describes the inclination to choose immediate pleasure or rewards over waiting for a potentially more substantial but delayed benefit. It often involves the pursuit of immediate pleasure without considering long-term consequences.
OVER-GRATIFICATION: Over-gratification refers to not receiving sufficient pleasure or fulfilment at a particular stage of personality development, potentially leading to psychological issues later in life.
UNDER-GRATIFICATION: Conversely, under-gratification refers to receiving excessive pleasure or satisfaction at a specific stage of personality development, which can also affect psychological development.
PLEASURE PRINCIPLE: The pleasure principle, associated with the id in Freud's model of the mind, represents the innate drive to seek immediate gratification of one's needs to experience pleasure and avoid pain. When basic needs are not met, it can lead to feelings of anxiety.
REALITY PRINCIPLE: In Freudian psychology, the reality principle contrasts with the pleasure principle. It refers to the mind's ability to assess external reality and adapt behaviour accordingly, considering not only immediate pleasure but also the consequences of actions.
EGO IDEAL: Part of the superego, the ego ideal comprises standards, values, and moral ideals that an individual internalizes. Failure to meet these standards can result in feelings of guilt, while success can enhance self-esteem.
EROGENOUS ZONES: Erogenous zones are areas of the body that are particularly sensitive to stimulation and can elicit pleasurable sensations. Freud associated specific erogenous zones with different stages of psychosexual development.
FIXATION: Fixation occurs when an individual becomes overly attached or invested in a particular developmental stage due to unresolved conflicts during that stage. This fixation can influence later behaviour and personality traits.
LIBIDO: The term libido encompasses one's sexual desires and more broadly, the mental energy responsible for one's sex drive. According to Freud, this concept suggests that sexual interest persists throughout life and plays a role in various activities involving sexual desire or affection.
THANATOS: In Freudian theory, Thanatos represents the death drive, highlighting the inherent tendency toward entropy and the dissolution of life forces. It counterbalances the life drive, known as Eros, which strives to sustain life.
EROS: Eros, the life force, represents the drive to sustain and propagate life. It encompasses the desires and attractions that promote life and connection.
THE OEDIPUS COMPLEX: Freud used the Oedipus complex to describe a developmental stage in childhood, typically occurring between ages three and six. It involves a child's desire to have a parent of the opposite sex exclusively, excluding the other parent. This concept is drawn from the Greek myth of Oedipus.
THE ELEKTRA COMPLEX: Coined by Jung as the female counterpart to the Oedipus complex, the Elektra complex describes a young girl's desire to have her father to herself while excluding her mother. Freud continued to use the term Oedipus complex for both genders but acknowledged the existence of a similar phenomenon in girls.
THE ICEBERG ANALOGY OF THE PSYCHE
Freud came up with a unique way of looking at the human mind. One significant change was to rename the mind “the psyche” and suggest that it was divided into three parts: a part that is conscious, a part that is pre-conscious and a larger part that is completely unconscious. To explain the concept of conscious versus unconscious experience, Freud compared the mind to an iceberg He said that only about one-tenth of our mind is conscious, and the rest of our mind is unconscious.
Three Levels of Awareness/consciousness: The concept of the three levels of awareness—conscious, preconscious, and unconscious—closely aligns with Freud's theory of the tripartite personality, consisting of the id, ego, and superego. These three levels and components of the psyche are interconnected and play a fundamental role in shaping human behaviour and understanding the human mind.
Correspondence Between Levels:
Conscious Mind: The conscious mind corresponds to the ego in Freud's model. It represents the aspect of the psyche that is readily accessible to awareness and encompasses thoughts, feelings, and perceptions that are currently active and consciously experienced.
Preconscious Mind: The preconscious mind aligns with elements of both the ego and the superego. It includes thoughts, memories, and information that are not immediately conscious but can be brought into consciousness with ease. The ego primarily operates within this realm, dealing with conscious and preconscious thoughts and desires, while also considering the superego's demands.
Unconscious Mind: The unconscious mind is associated with the id in Freud's model. It constitutes the deepest and most hidden layer of the psyche, containing repressed memories, primal instincts, and desires. Like the id, the unconscious mind operates outside of conscious awareness and can influence behaviour in subtle and unexpected ways. Note: writers—like Freud—tend to use the word “unconscious” rather than “subconscious.”
A critical element to understanding the psyche is that the unconscious mind is completely inaccessible to the conscious mind. Nobody can "look inside themselves" and understand their unconscious thoughts.
Overlap and Interaction: These three levels of awareness and the components of the tripartite personality—id, ego, and superego—constantly interact and influence each other. The ego mediates between the impulsive, pleasure-seeking id and the moralistic, conscience-driven superego. It operates within the conscious and preconscious realms, striving to balance the conflicting demands of these two elements.
Understanding this correspondence between levels of awareness and the tripartite personality provides insight into how human behaviour, thoughts, and emotions are shaped by the interplay of these psychological components, contributing to a comprehensive understanding of the complexities of the human mind.
THREE PARTS OF THE PSYCHE: THE TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY
The three levels of awareness are the conscious, preconscious, and unconscious. Corresponds to and overlaps with Freud's ideas of the id, ego, and superego; known collectively as the tripartite personality.
According to Freud, the three parts develop over the first five years of early life. Thus, for Freud, early childhood is the most important stage in human life as it is the stage when the psyche forms and shapes behaviour for the entire life span.
Two principles to consider: Freud contrasted the pleasure principle with the counterpart concept of the reality principle, which describes the capacity to defer gratification of a desire when circumstantial reality disallows its immediate gratification. In infancy and early childhood, the id rules behaviour by obeying only the pleasure principle. People at that age only seek immediate gratification, aiming to satisfy cravings such as hunger and thirst, and at later ages, the id seeks out sex. Maturity is learning to endure the pain of deferred gratification. Freud argued that "an ego thus educated has become 'reasonable'; it no longer lets itself be governed by the pleasure principle, but obeys the reality principle, which also, at the bottom, seeks to obtain pleasure, but pleasure, which is assured through taking account of reality, even though it is pleasure postponed and diminished”.
THE ID = THE DEVIL
THE iD IS PRESENT FROM BIRTH
THE iD = THE DEVIL
The id is present from birth. It constitutes the most fundamental aspect of the psyche, developing first in babies. The id is comprised of urges and desires. It lacks rationality and reflection, consisting entirely of feelings. It resides wholly in the unconscious mind. It's important to note that the id is distinct from "ID" as in an identification card or identity. In fact, many of us share similar id-driven desires: food, drink, sex, sleep, and fun. The id operates on the "pleasure principle" without comprehending logic, time, or the external world. It demands immediate gratification; it wants what it wants, and it wants it NOW. Denying the id its pleasure can lead to frustration. The id itself is not evil; most of its desires are essential for our well-being – without eating or sleeping, we would perish, and the continuation of our species relies on sexual reproduction. The challenge lies in the id's inability to impose restraint, delay gratification, or acknowledge others. It lives solely for the moment and is entirely self-centred. However, immediately satisfying these needs isn't always practical or feasible. If the pleasure principle entirely governed us, we might grab desired items from others to fulfil our cravings. Such behaviour would be disruptive and socially unacceptable. According to Freud, the id attempts to resolve the tension arising from the pleasure principle through the primary process, involving the creation of a mental image of the desired object as a means of satisfying the need.
IN SHORT
The ID = The Devil: This analogy suggests that the id can be viewed metaphorically as the "devil" within us, representing our most basic, impulsive, and often selfish desires.
Present from Birth: According to Freud, the id is present from birth and represents the most primitive part of the psyche.
Urges and Desires: The id is primarily driven by urges and desires, operating to fulfil immediate needs.
Unconscious: The id operates entirely within the unconscious mind, meaning its processes and desires are not readily accessible to conscious awareness.
Feelings over Logic: Unlike the ego and superego, the id is not rational or reflective. It is primarily composed of raw emotions and desires.
Pleasure Principle: The id operates based on the pleasure principle, seeking immediate gratification of its desires without considering logic, time, or external constraints.
Immediate Gratification: The id seeks what it wants immediately and lacks patience for delay or postponement. It operates on a "want it now" basis.
THE EGO =THE REFEREE
THE EGO DEVELOPS IN THE FIRST THREE YEARS OF LIFE
The ego is the second part of the psyche, typically developing in toddlers. It serves as the thinking and decision-making component of the mind. Unlike the id, the ego operates within the conscious mind and adheres to the "reality principle." This means it comprehends the outside world, the consequences of actions, and the passage of time. Importantly, the ego does not possess its own desires; rather, its role is to find ways to fulfil the desires that emanate from the id. This is made possible because the ego understands the real world and can formulate plans and strategies.
One of the ego's powerful tools for managing the id is deferred gratification. Deferred gratification involves postponing immediate pleasure or opting for a smaller immediate pleasure in exchange for a larger one in the future. The ego convinces the id to desire something less immediately pleasurable, such as doing household chores, by promising a more enjoyable reward later, like indulging in pizza. In essence, the ego "persuades" the id into undertaking tasks with the promise of future enjoyment. It's important to note that while the ego comprehends punishment and seeks to avoid it, it does not experience guilt.
The ego plays a crucial role in managing the id's impulses in a socially acceptable manner, ensuring that desires can be expressed in ways suitable for the real world. It functions in the conscious, preconscious, and unconscious mind. Operating based on the reality principle, the ego seeks to satisfy the id's desires realistically and in socially appropriate ways. It carefully assesses the costs and benefits of actions before deciding to act upon or suppress impulses. In many instances, the ego allows the satisfaction of id impulses through delayed gratification, permitting the behaviour at the appropriate time and place. The ego also relieves tension arising from unmet impulses through the secondary process, which involves searching for real-world objects that match the mental images created by the id's primary process
THE SUPER-EGO = THE ANGEL
THE SUPEREGO DEVELOPS ABOUT THE AGE OF FIVE.
THE SUPER-EGO: MORALITY AND CONSCIENCE
Development and Role: The final component of the psyche to develop is the super-ego, which typically forms between the ages of 4 and 6. This aspect of personality holds our internalised moral standards and ideals acquired from parents and society, shaping our sense of right and wrong. The super-ego operates at the intersection of the conscious and unconscious mind, with partial awareness. It operates based on the "morality principle" and serves as the "voice of conscience," evaluating the moral acceptability of the ego's thoughts and actions.
Guilt and Shame: When the super-ego objects to the ego's thoughts or actions, it triggers feelings of guilt and shame. These emotions can be challenging for the ego to endure, leading it to generate thoughts and plans that align with the super-ego's moral standards. This can be a complex process, as the id continues to generate needs and desires that may conflict with the super-ego's moral restrictions.
Understanding the Super-Ego: It's important to clarify that the super-ego isn't inherently "good," nor is the id "evil." The super-ego represents the desire for self-punishment, feelings of unworthiness, and a sense of failure. A powerful super-ego doesn't necessarily make an individual a morally upright person. In fact, Freud suggests that individuals with powerful super-egos may commit crimes due to an unconscious desire for punishment.
TWO COMPONENTS OF THE SUPER-EGO
Ego Ideal: This aspect includes rules and standards for good behaviour, reflecting the behaviours approved of by parental and authority figures. Adhering to these rules generates feelings of pride, value, and accomplishment.
Conscience: The conscience contains information about behaviours viewed as bad by parents and society. These behaviours are often forbidden and lead to negative consequences, punishments, or feelings of guilt and remorse.
Role Across Consciousness Levels: The super-ego operates in the conscious, preconscious, and unconscious mind, striving to refine and civilize human behaviour. It aims to suppress unacceptable id impulses and guide the ego toward idealistic standards rather than purely realistic principles.
THE EGO'S DEFENCE MECHANISMS AND THE UNCONSCIOUS
Conflict Resolution: The ego faces the challenge of mediating between the demands of the id and the constraints of reality. To address this conflict, it employs defence mechanisms designed to protect itself. These mechanisms serve to either restrict the id's demands or transform them into forms that no longer offend the super-ego. Defence mechanisms can also operate by blocking out aspects of reality that overwhelm the ego, offend the super-ego, or frighten the id.
Protecting the Mind: In response to life's difficulties and the presence of undesirable thoughts and behaviours, the ego uses defence mechanisms to safeguard the psyche. These mechanisms serve to shield us from unpleasant thoughts, such as those related to sex, aggression and hate. Additionally, they can address maladaptive behaviours like revenge, addiction, overeating, and anxiety. Defence mechanisms are essentially unconscious desires masquerading as ego defence mechanisms.
Freudian Perspective on Defence Mechanisms: According to Freud, we all employ various defence mechanisms to maintain psychological and emotional well-being. However, these mechanisms can become problematic when they become the predominant means of coping with stress. While they serve a protective function, they often involve self-deception and distortion of reality, potentially hindering the effective resolution of underlying issues. These mechanisms are typically learned during early childhood and develop as ways to cope with inner hurt, pain, anger, anxiety, sadness, and self-devaluation. They operate automatically and habitually.
Understanding these defence mechanisms sheds light on how the human psyche copes with challenges and maintains equilibrium, although they can become problematic if overused or relied upon excessively.
EGO DEFENCE MECHANISMS
ACCUSING: Blaming someone or something else for one's behaviour, such as accusing others of causing one's drinking or drug use.
ANALYSING: Engaging in rationalisation by justifying increased substance use due to a specific reason, often with the belief that it will decrease over time.
ARGUING: Denying an addiction problem by pointing out that no severe consequences, such as fines or legal issues, have occurred.
ATTENTION-GETTING: Creating situations that make oneself appear important or the victim to divert attention from underlying feelings of failure and insecurity.
BLAMING: Holding others responsible for one's substance abuse, like attributing it to job stress or external factors.
COCKINESS: Overcompensating for insecurities by adopting an arrogant or overly confident attitude, viewing oneself as superior to others.
COMPENSATION: Masking personal weaknesses by highlighting desirable qualities or attempting to compensate for frustrations in one area of life with excessive gratification in another.
COMPLIANCE: Conforming to others' expectations and demands to avoid facing personal issues or conflicts.
CONVERSION: Transforming emotional struggles into physical symptoms or ailments, effectively transferring psychological distress into bodily complaints.
DEFIANCE: Challenging others to prove one's addiction, is often used as a defence mechanism to deny the problem.
DENIAL OF REALITY: Refusing to acknowledge or face an unpleasant reality or situation to protect oneself from its emotional impact.
DISPLACEMENT: Redirecting intense emotions, typically hostility, from their initial source to less threatening objects or individuals.
EMOTIONAL INSULATION: Reducing emotional engagement and adopting a passive demeanour to shield oneself from emotional hurt.
EXPLAINING: Offering justifications or explanations for one's substance abuse, attempting to rationalise or excuse the behaviour.
FANTASY: Escaping into imaginary achievements or idealised scenarios to fulfil unmet desires or cope with reality, often used as an excuse by individuals struggling with addiction.
HUMOUR: Using humour to downplay the seriousness of an issue, including addiction, as a way to avoid confronting it.
IDEALISATION: Extensively admiring oneself or others, often to an unrealistic and exaggerated degree.
IDENTIFICATION: Aligning oneself with another person, group, or profession as a means to overcome feelings of inferiority or insecurity.
INTELLECTUALISING: Attempting to analyse and intellectualise the problem by citing research or data that suggests the absence of an addiction issue.
JUDGING: Blaming others for the problems or challenges faced, suggesting that things would improve if they behaved differently.
JUSTIFYING: Providing reasons or excuses to rationalise substance abuse, often by shifting blame to external factors or circumstances.
LYING: Misrepresenting the extent of substance use, minimising it to appear less problematic.
MANIPULATION: Using manipulative tactics, such as making deals or promises, to divert attention from one's addiction or to avoid confrontation.
MINIMISING: Downplaying one's substance use by comparing it to others, making it seem less severe than it actually is.
PROJECTING: Attributing one's manipulative behaviours or desires to others, deflecting attention from one's actions.
PROJECTION: Placing blame on others for difficulties or projecting one's unethical desires onto them.
RATIONALISING: Justifying one's actions to ease feelings of guilt or discomfort, often by emphasising the absence of a daily or constant problem.
REACTION FORMATION: Preventing the expression of undesirable desires by adopting exaggerated opposing attitudes or behaviours as a defence mechanism, for example, being homophobic while secretly harbouring same-sex attractions.
REGRESSION: Seeking to return to a state of childhood and escape adult responsibilities or stressors.
REPRESSION: Keeping distressing or dangerous thoughts and memories out of conscious awareness to avoid confronting them.
SELF-PITY: Attributing personal failures or difficulties to fate or bad luck, adopting a defeatist attitude.
SUBLIMATION: Redirecting one's drives or impulses toward a socially acceptable and productive goal when the original goal becomes unattainable.
THREATENING: Using threats to intimidate or discourage others from confronting or intervening in one's addiction.
WITHDRAWING: Responding to stressors or confrontations by withdrawing from social interactions or emotional engagement. This can manifest as shouting, silence, nervousness, or physical withdrawal.
VARIATIONS IN THE TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY
It is easy to see how conflict might arise between the id, ego, and superego, as they are three competing forces, Freud used the term ego strength to refer to the ego's ability to function despite these duelling forces. A person with good ego strength can effectively manage these pressures, while those with too much or too little ego strength can become too unyielding or too disrupting. Freud compared the Id and superego to a horse and the ego to the horse's rider. The horse provides power and motion, yet the rider provides direction and guidance. Without its rider, the horse may wander wherever it wished and do whatever it pleased. The rider instead gives the horse directions and commands to guide it in the direction he or she wishes to go.
According to Freud, the key to a healthy personality is a balance between the id, the ego, and the superego.
The Tripartite personality theory applied to the following extremely short scenario. Gwendoline walks into the kitchen, nobody is home. On the table is her favourite chocolate cake, what do she do?
APPLICATION OF THE TRI-PARTITE PERSONALITY THEORY
Scenario: Gwendoline and the Chocolate Cake
ID DOMINANT: In this scenario, an individual with a dominant id would succumb to their immediate desires without considering the consequences. Gwendoline, driven by her id, would choose to devour the entire chocolate cake because she cannot resist the urge to indulge in its deliciousness. The fact that the cake belongs to someone else is of little concern to her.
Possible Manifestations:
Anti-social personality disorder
Addiction
Obesity
Alcoholism
Violence
Sexual crimes
Theft
Narcissistic personality disorder
Fraud
Psychopathy (anti-personality disorder)
Slothfulness
Delinquency
ABH (Actual Bodily Harm)
GBH (Grievous Bodily Harm)
Manslaughter
Drunk/drug driving
Gambling addiction
Promiscuity
Shopping addiction
Surgery addiction
EGO DOMINANT: An individual with a dominant ego can effectively mediate between the id's desires and the superego's moral standards. In this case, Gwendoline would display self-control. She would opt to consume only a small slice of the cake and, recognizing her wrongdoing, leave a note confessing her actions. Her ego restrains her id's cravings, considering the consequences of stealing and consuming unhealthy food.
Possible Manifestations:
Responsible decision-making
Conscience-driven actions
Ethical behaviour
SUPEREGO DOMINANT: When an individual's superego dominates, it may overpower the ego's ability to restrain desires. Gwendoline, in this instance, would not yield to the temptation of the chocolate cake, as her strong superego strictly adheres to moral standards and inhibits her actions. She refrains from indulging, considering both the ownership of the cake and its health implications.
Possible Manifestations:
Anorexia Nervosa
OCD (Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder)
Hoarding
Anxiety
Phobias
Depression
PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder)
Body dysmorphia
Gender dysmorphia
Sexual dysfunction problems or inhibition
Inhibited self-harm
Social anxiety
Excessive focus on physical health and appearance, such as becoming a gym fanatic or diet/health fanatic
This scenario demonstrates how the dominance of one component of the tripartite personality—id, ego, or superego—can influence an individual's decisions and actions in response to a tempting situation, ultimately shaping their behaviour and its consequences.
FREUD’S MODEL OF PSYCHO-SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT
But how does the Tripartite personality develop, in other words, how does somebody become iDd dominant, or superego dominant and if they are lucky, balanced? According to Freud, these variations are due to the experiences a person has during their psychosexual development which takes place during childhood.
Freud observed that children's behaviour often orients around certain body parts like the mouth during breastfeeding, the anus during toilet training, and later the genitals at around the age of four. Because of his work previous work with hysterical patients, Freud also believed that adult neurosis often has roots in childhood sexuality,
Freud proposed that these abnormal behaviours were childhood expressions of sexual fantasy and desire. He suggested that humans are born "polymorphously perverse", meaning that infants can derive sexual pleasure from any part of the body. And that it is only through socialisation that sexual drives are focused on adult heterosexuality.
Freud developed a model for what he considered to be the "normal" sexual development of the child, which he called "libido development". According to this theory, each child passes through five psychosexual stages. During each stage, the libido has a different erogenous zone as the source of its drives. The libido refers to various kinds of sensual pleasures and gratifications.
However, in the pursuit of satisfying these sexual urges, the child may experience failure or reprimands from his parents or society and may thus come to associate anxiety with this erogenous zone. To avoid this anxiety, the child becomes preoccupied with themes related to this zone, a phenomenon Freud termed fixation. Freud believed the fixation persists into adulthood and underlies the personality structure and psychopathology, including neurosis, hysteria and personality disorders. Freud called this psychosexual infantilism.
The psychosexual stages are as follows:
ORAL STAGE
AGE RANGE: 0 - 1/2 years
EROGENOUS ZONE(S): Mouth
PART OF TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT: Ego development. Problems at the oral stage can result in a weak Ego or disintegrated Ego.
The oral stage encompasses the initial phase of a child's psychosexual development, extending from birth to roughly 21 months of age. During this period, the infant's primary source of pleasure and exploration is centred on their mouth and lips. These oral activities mainly revolve around sucking and feeding, which are essential for their survival and nourishment.
Infants in the oral stage display a characteristic behaviour of putting various objects into their mouths, including hands, fingers, toys, pacifiers, and even items of clothing, as a means of exploring and understanding the world around them. This oral exploration is a fundamental way for infants to interact with and learn about their environment.
One of the central elements of the oral stage is breastfeeding, particularly from the mother's breast. This act of nursing fulfils the infant's critical need for sustenance and nourishment. It is a dependent act, crucial for the infant's survival, and it plays a defining role during this stage.
In terms of psychological development, the oral stage is characterized by the dominance of the Id, the most primitive aspect of the psyche. Neither the Ego nor the Superego is fully formed at this early stage of life. Consequently, the infant lacks a well-defined sense of self, and the pleasure principle primarily drives their actions. In simple terms, the infant seeks immediate gratification of their desires and needs, guided solely by their instinctual impulses.
While the Id holds sway during the oral stage, the formation of the Ego begins to take shape. Two critical factors influence the development of the Ego:
Body Image: Infants begin to differentiate their bodily boundaries from the external world. They gradually learn that sensations such as pain occur when external force is applied to their own body. This process contributes to the emerging sense of self or ego.
Delayed Gratification: Experiences involving delayed gratification become significant during this stage. The infant gradually realizes that immediate gratification is not always possible and that specific behaviours can lead to satisfying their needs. For instance, crying, which initially appears purposeless, later becomes a productive way to communicate needs.
A significant event in the oral stage is weaning, which involves the gradual withdrawal of the infant from their primary source of nourishment, whether it be the mother's milk, a bottle, or a pacifier. This experience introduces the infant to the first sense of loss and limitation they have ever encountered. It serves as a crucial moment in developing self-awareness, independence, and trust.
According to Freud, how an individual experiences weaning during this stage can have lasting effects on their adult personality. Fixation during the oral stage can manifest in two primary ways:
Orally Passive Fixation: This occurs when an infant is overindulged during nursing or weaning. Constantly having their feeding needs met can lead to the development of a dependent, helpless, and entitled adult. Signs of an orally passive fixation may include behaviours such as smoking, drug use, overeating, and obsessions with activities involving the mouth.
Orally Aggressive Fixation: Conversely, when infants face neglect during this stage, experiencing premature termination of nursing or insufficient attention to their needs, they can develop an orally aggressive fixation. This can result in the development of an envious, suspicious, and pessimistic adult personality. Signs may include behaviours like excessive gum-chewing or pen-chewing.
In summary, the oral stage represents a crucial phase in psychosexual development where the infant's interactions with feeding, weaning, and oral exploration significantly shape their early experiences and have lasting implications for their adult personality and behaviours. The stage represents the dominance of the Id and the beginning of Ego formation, along with crucial lessons about delayed gratification and self-awareness. The consequences of fixation during this stage can lead to either passive or aggressive behaviours in adulthood. Cultural variations may influence the duration of breastfeeding during this stage, but the act of sucking and eating remains universal early memory for infants across societies.
ANAL STAGE
AGE RANGE: 2-3 years
EROGENOUS ZONE(S): Bowel and bladder elimination
PART OF TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT: EGO Obsession with organisation or excessive neatness
When parents adopt an authoritarian approach to a child's toilet training, involving scolding, punishments, or disappointment, it can have a profound impact on the child's emerging sense of self-expression. In such situations, emotional suppression, fear, and embarrassment related to emotions may ensue. These emotional consequences can manifest in various ways, ranging from an obsession with maintaining an excessively orderly environment to sexual repression, anxiety, or social phobia.
In cases where parents react strongly to the child's behaviour, compliance might indeed occur, but this often comes at the cost of a weakened sense of self. In such instances, parents assume control of the situation, overshadowing the development of the child's ego. On the contrary, when a child prioritises id-driven desires and parents acquiesce to these demands, it can lead to the development of a messy and self-indulgent personality.
The resolution of this conflict can be gradual and non-traumatic, or intense and stormy, depending on the methods the parents will use to handle the situation.
PHALLIC STAGE
AGE RANGE: 4-6 years
EROGENOUS ZONE(S): Genitals
PART OF TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT: SUPEREGO
During the phallic stage of psychosexual development, which typically spans from three to five years of age, the primary erogenous zone is the genital area. It's important to note that gratification in this stage does not resemble adult sexuality due to the physical immaturity of children. Nevertheless, genital stimulation is considered pleasurable during this period. Children, particularly boys, may experience erections during sleep, akin to adult males.
Children in this stage become increasingly aware of their bodies and begin to exhibit curiosity about the bodies of their peers and parents. Freud observed common behaviours during this stage, such as children undressing and engaging in "doctor" play or asking their mothers about genital differences. These observations led Freud to conclude that gratification is predominantly focused on and around the genital region during the phallic stage.
The central conflict in this stage is known as the Oedipal conflict, named after the mythological figure Oedipus, who unintentionally killed his father and entered into a relationship with his mother. Freud applied the term "Oedipal" to both boys and girls, although later analysts introduced the "Electra complex" as a counterpart for females. Initially, for children of both sexes, the primary caregiver and source of gratification is typically the mother. However, as children develop, their sexual identity formation leads to shifts in dynamics.
MALES
For boys, the mother becomes an object of desire, while the father becomes a source of jealousy and rivalry. The id seeks to unite with the mother and eliminate the father, but the ego, guided by the reality principle, recognises the father's physical strength. The child also harbours affectionate feelings for the father, who is one of the primary caregivers. The id's fear that the father will disapprove of these emotions is expressed as castration anxiety, which is irrational and unconscious.
FEMALES
Freud argued that girls undergo a similar psychosexual development as boys. While boys develop castration anxiety, girls experience penis envy—a feeling of envy toward males due to their possession of a penis. This envy arises from the belief that without a penis, females cannot sexually possess the mother as the id desires. Consequently, girls are driven to seek sexual union with their fathers. Girls go through an additional stage where they must relinquish the clitoris's sensitivity and importance to the vagina. This transition marks the girl's movement toward heterosexual femininity and the eventual capacity to give birth, with her child symbolically taking the place of the penis.
In general, Freud believed that the Oedipal conflict experienced by girls was more intense than that experienced by boys, potentially resulting in a more submissive and less confident personality.
RESOLUTION
In both cases, the resolution of the conflict between id drives and ego is achieved through two primary ego defence mechanisms. One is repression, which blocks memories, impulses, and ideas from conscious awareness but does not resolve the conflict. The second mechanism is identification, where the child incorporates characteristics of the same-sex parent into their ego. In the case of boys, this mechanism is employed to reduce castration fears by making them more similar to their fathers. Girls tend to find identification with their mothers easier, as neither they nor their mothers possess a penis.
Freud's theories regarding feminine sexuality, including penis envy, have faced criticism from gender theory and feminist theory.
FIXATIONS
Failure to resolve the Oedipal conflict can lead to fixation in this stage, resulting in various adult behaviours. Women may strive for superiority over men, exhibit seductive or flirtatious behaviour, or demonstrate excessive submissiveness and low self-esteem. In contrast, men may display excessive ambition and vanity. Overall, the Oedipal conflict plays a crucial role in super-ego development, as it involves internalizing morality through identification with one of the parents. A weak identification with the opposite-sex parent may lead to recklessness or immorality.
HOMOSEXUALITY AND UNRESOLVED CONFLICTS
Sigmund Freud's interpretation of homosexuality, as outlined in his early psychoanalytic theories, posited that homosexuality resulted from unresolved conflicts in psychosexual development. Specifically, Freud suggested that homosexuality could be linked to disturbances during the Oedipal complex or Electra complex stages, depending on an individual's gender.
For male homosexuality, Freud proposed that a boy's unresolved Oedipal complex, where he develops strong feelings of love and attachment to his mother and rivalry with his father, could contribute to homosexual tendencies. According to Freud, if a boy did not successfully resolve this complex by identifying with his father and internalizing societal norms, he might retain his attachment to his mother and develop homosexual inclinations.
THE ELECTRA COMPLEX
For female homosexuality, Freud's theory involved the Electra complex. Freud suggested that a girl's development of penis envy (the envy of the male's perceived anatomical advantage) could lead to unresolved conflicts. If these conflicts persisted, they might contribute to homosexual tendencies in women, as they could seek to compensate for the perceived lack of a penis through relationships with other women.
In later revisions of Freud's theories, particularly by other psychoanalysts, the concept of the Electra complex underwent refinements and extensions. One notable revision was introduced by Carl Jung, who emphasized the importance of the Electra complex in the development of female sexuality. Jung expanded upon Freud's ideas and explored the concept of the "Electra archetype," which encompassed a broader range of experiences and symbols related to female development and individuation.
LATENCY STAGE
AGE RANGE: 7-10 years (until puberty)
EROGENOUS ZONE(S): Dormant sexual feelings
PART OF TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT: None as all the parts of the tripartite personality are formed in the first five years of life.
The latency stage in psychosexual development represents a period characterized by the consolidation of the habits and behaviours that the child developed in earlier stages. Regardless of whether the Oedipal conflict was successfully resolved during the previous stage, the id's drives do not influence the ego during this latency stage. These drives are considered dormant and concealed (latent), and the gratification experienced by the child is not as immediate as it was in the earlier stages. Instead, pleasure is primarily related to secondary process thinking.
During this stage, the energy previously focused on psychosexual drives is redirected towards new activities, primarily related to education, hobbies, and forming friendships. However, challenges may arise during this stage. Inadequate repression of the Oedipal conflict or the ego's inability to redirect drive energy toward socially acceptable activities can lead to problems in this latency stage of development. These issues may manifest as behavioural or emotional difficulties, potentially impacting the child's overall development.
GENITAL STAGE
AGE RANGE: 11+ years(Puberty and beyond)
EROGENOUS ZONE(S): Sexual interests mature
PART OF TRIPARTITE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT: None as all the parts of the tripartite personality are formed in the first five years of life.
The final stage of psychosexual development, known as the genital stage, begins during puberty, typically around the age of twelve, and continues into adulthood, ideally concluding around the age of eighteen when adulthood officially commences. This stage encompasses a significant portion of an individual's life and involves several key developmental tasks.
One primary task during the genital stage is achieving detachment from one's parents. It marks a period where individuals strive to reconcile and come to terms with any unresolved issues or conflicts from their early childhood experiences. Unlike previous stages, the genital stage renews the focus on the genitals, similar to the phallic stage. However, there are crucial differences.
In the genital stage, sexual energy is expressed in the context of adult sexuality. Unlike the phallic stage, where gratification is primarily linked to the satisfaction of primary drives, the ego in the genital stage has matured and employs secondary process thinking. This allows for symbolic gratification, which may involve forming love relationships, starting families, or embracing the responsibilities associated with adulthood. It represents a period of psychological maturation and the development of more complex, adult-oriented relationships and behaviours.
EVALUATION OF THE PSYCHODYNAMIC APPROACH
ADVANTAGES
Sigmund Freud's theories have left an indelible mark on psychology and twentieth-century thought. Many of his concepts, particularly defence mechanisms like repression and denial, have become well-known and are widely applied in various contexts.
In cases of sexual abuse, individuals often employ repression, a defence mechanism where distressing memories or thoughts are pushed into the unconscious to protect the conscious mind from overwhelming emotions.
Denial, another defence mechanism, is commonly observed in various aspects of life, including addiction. People struggling with addiction may deny the severity of their problem or the harmful consequences of their actions.
Freudian ideas have also made significant inroads into fields like literary criticism, where analysts explore the unconscious elements in literature, and art and design, where symbolism and unconscious influences are studied and integrated into creative work.
Furthermore, Freudian terminology and concepts have permeated everyday language, making phrases like "Freudian slip" or "ego" part of our common vocabulary, reflecting the enduring impact of Freud's contributions on our understanding of human behaviour and the mind.
Freud introduced novel treatments for individuals grappling with mental health issues that were previously unavailable or even considered inhumane. Before the advent of psychoanalysis, individuals with mental illnesses often found themselves confined to institutions for extended periods, sometimes for life.
Critics of psychoanalysis have argued that it tends to cater to the affluent due to its high cost and time-consuming nature. Notably, it is typically not covered by publicly-funded healthcare systems like the NHS. Furthermore, many individuals undergoing psychoanalysis are not severely mentally ill, particularly in terms of psychotic conditions. Instead, they often seek treatment for the challenges posed by modern Western life, such as depression, anxiety, and contemporary existential concerns related to fidelity, inhibition, and other issues. FREUD DID NOT TREAT PSYCHOTIC ILLNESS
Additionally, it's important to recognise that Freud's development of treatments was closely tied to the complex and abstract theories and concepts he proposed. In essence, psychoanalysis served as both a therapeutic approach and a means of exploring and substantiating his groundbreaking ideas about the human mind.
Freud's theory was meticulously constructed through in-depth case studies that offered profound and comprehensive insights into human behaviour and psychology. These case studies, including his research such as the famous Little Hans case, formed the foundation of his theoretical framework. They provided him with a wealth of valid and detailed data on which to base his ideas.
Central to Freud's approach was focusing on the unique dreams, issues, and experiences of each individual he studied. This personalized examination allowed him to develop a theory that was rooted in the complexities of human psychology and behaviour, making it a significant contribution to the field of psychology.
DISADVANTAGES
NOT A COMPREHENSIVE THEORY
A major criticism of psychodynamic theories, like Freud’s, is that they are not very comprehensive because they don’t explore the full spectrum of human behaviours. For example, psychodynamic theories don’t investigate higher mental functions such as intelligence, memory or attention. Psychodynamic approaches are primarily about mental illnesses rather than the workings of the neuro-typical brain. Plomin believes that Freud sent society looking in the wrong place for answers to the question of what makes us as we are. The key to personality traits does not lie in how your parents treated you, but rather in what you inherited biologically from them: namely, the genes in your DNA. The main draw of psychodynamic theories is their ability to explain why some behaviours and emotions are deviant, and some behaviours are not.
CULTURAL AND TEMPORAL BOUNDARIES:
Critics contend that psychodynamic theory is bound by cultural and temporal limitations, diminishing its relevance in modern and diverse cultural contexts. This perspective highlights the theory's origins in a specific historical and cultural milieu.
During Freud's era, when attitudes toward emotions and sexuality were more repressive, psychodynamic theory gained popularity, particularly in Europe and the USA. The theory's concepts and interpretations were rooted in the cultural norms of that time.
FOCUS ON VIENNESE WOMEN:
Another criticism points out that Freud's case studies and treatment primarily involved middle-aged women from Vienna. These individuals were often characterized by emotional repression and conservative attitudes toward sexuality.
Critics argue that the overrepresentation of this specific demographic in Freud's work may limit the theory's applicability to a broader and more diverse population.
EVOLUTION OF CULTURAL AND SOCIAL NORMS:
Critics argue that significant changes in cultural and social norms, particularly regarding openness about emotions and sexuality, have occurred since Freud's time. These changes have rendered some of Freud's assumptions and interpretations outdated and less relevant in contemporary society.
ADAPTATION CHALLENGES:
The rigid adherence to psychodynamic principles may pose challenges in adapting the theory to accommodate the evolving needs and beliefs of individuals from different cultural backgrounds and periods.
MISOGYNISTIC
The psychodynamic approach has faced criticism for its historical bias towards females. Freud's belief in concepts like penis envy and the resulting idea of female inferiority have been contentious points of contention. According to Freud, females were considered inferior to males because of their supposed penis envy. He also suggested that females tended to develop weaker superegos and were more prone to anxiety due to their inability to go through the Oedipus complex, which was seen as a male-oriented concept.
Psychologist Karen Horney challenged Freud's theories, labelling them as inaccurate and demeaning to women. Horney proposed an alternative perspective, suggesting that men experience feelings of inferiority because they cannot give birth to children, a concept she termed "womb envy."
Supporters of Freud argue that he was not necessarily misogynistic but rather reflected the prevailing societal norms and attitudes of his time. During the 19th century, women were indeed treated as second-class citizens. Men enjoyed legal, social, educational, and economic advantages over women. In this context, the penis symbolized not just physical attributes but also the power and freedom that men possessed.
In the 1800s, women faced severe limitations in terms of rights and opportunities. They could not vote, work in many professions, own property, or inherit titles. Financial independence was challenging to achieve unless they received an inheritance from a wealthy father or became widows. Women needed to secure advantageous marriages for financial security because there was no welfare state to provide support. The limited options available to women during this era help explain why they might have envied the social and economic advantages that men enjoyed.
SOCIALLY SENSITIVE RESEARCH
Freud's theory has been criticised for its social sensitivity, particularly for the potential harm it may cause by blaming parents, especially mothers, for their child's deviant behaviour. Such blame could lead to these parents being stigmatised and marginalised in society. It raises the question of why mothers are consistently singled out for blame. Research has proved that mothers are not solely responsible for shaping their children's personalities (Neill, 1990).
The idea that mothers are to blame for their children's mental health issues, as suggested by the schizophrenogenic mother theory, may be rooted in the fact that females traditionally take on the bulk of child-rearing responsibilities. However, this assumption doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Psychoanalytic theories often carry misogynistic assumptions, as most mothers of schizophrenic individuals do not fit the stereotype of being harsh and withholding, as assumed by Fromme-Reichman.
Research by Waring and Rick (1965) found that mothers of mentally fragile children tended to exhibit traits such as anxiety, shyness, and withdrawal. These traits might be reflective of the tremendous stress and challenges associated with raising a child with a serious mental disorder. Therefore, it is important to recognise that blaming mothers or parents in general for their child's mental health issues is an oversimplification that can lead to unjust blame and ignores the complex interplay of various factors in a child's development.
NEO FREUDIANS (PSYCHODYNAMIC PERSPECTIVE: In contrast to the emphasis on sexuality in psychoanalysis, the psychodynamic)
This perspective places greater importance on the role of the social environment in shaping one's personality and behaviour.
Critics of Freud's theory argue that his work is more applicable to men and that it places excessive emphasis on early childhood and sexuality. Neo-Freudians represent a group of thinkers who diverge from Freud's perspective. They reject the notion that personality development is completed by age six and instead propose that it continues throughout the lifespan. Neo-Freudians have expanded upon Freud's ideas, incorporating a greater influence from the environment and emphasising the significance of conscious thought alongside the unconscious. They have also downplayed the centrality of sexuality and the Oedipus complex in their theories.
Key figures in this neo-Freudian movement include Erik Erikson, known for his work on psychosocial development, Anna Freud, Carl Jung, Alfred Adler, Karen Horney, and proponents of the object relations school of thought. These thinkers have enriched and evolved Freudian ideas to create a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of human development and personality.
DETERMINISTIC
Determinism in psychodynamic theories is evident in the sense that individuals are seen as having no control over the development of fixations, which are shaped by early family experiences. According to Freud, all thoughts, behaviours, and emotions are determined by these childhood experiences. While this perspective does not attribute these determinants to an individual's biology or free will, it still reflects a form of determinism.
The deterministic nature of psychodynamic theories can be seen as both positive and negative. On the positive side, it highlights the importance of understanding how expressed emotions can influence the exacerbation of symptoms of conditions like psychosis. However, on the negative side, it can lead to blame and guilt, particularly towards parents, as individuals may feel responsible for their fixations. Furthermore, this deterministic view may suggest limited personal agency or free will over one's behaviour, which can be seen as disheartening.
REDUCTIONIST
Psychodynamic explanations tend to be reductionist as they simplify the complex process of personality formation, primarily attributing it to early childhood trauma and personality issues. However, evidence from studies involving both identical (MZ) and non-identical (DZ) twins suggests that biology also plays a significant role in shaping an individual's character and personality.
To gain a more comprehensive understanding of personality development, it is crucial to adopt an eclectic approach that considers a broad range of factors, including both biological and environmental influences. Such an approach recognizes that personality is a complex interplay of various elements, and no single explanation can fully account for its complexity. By incorporating multiple perspectives, we can better understand how personality is formed and how it develops over time.
IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?
Psychodynamic theories heavily rely on evidence from Freud's case studies, such as those of Little Hans and Anna O. However, the case study method has its limitations, one of which is susceptibility to researcher bias. In some instances, re-examinations of Freud's clinical work have indicated that he may have distorted his patients' case histories to make them align more closely with his theoretical framework (Sulloway, 1991).
Additionally, case studies are typically focused on in-depth examinations of individual cases. This narrow focus can make it challenging to generalize findings to the broader population, as the experiences and behaviours of one person may not be representative of the entire world. Consequently, while case studies provide valuable insights, they should be complemented by other research methods to establish more robust and widely applicable conclusions in the field of psychology.
NOMOTHETIC, IDIOGRAPHIC OR BOTH?
Freud's theory is primarily nomothetic in nature, as it aims to establish general principles and explanations that apply to all individuals. However, it's important to note that the research methods often used to explore and validate Freud's theory, such as case studies, tend to be more idiographic in practice.
Case studies involve the in-depth examination of individual cases to gain a comprehensive understanding of specific phenomena. While this method is idiographic in its focus on unique cases, it is used to gather evidence and support broader nomothetic claims or theories.
So, while there may appear to be a paradox in the research approach, it's common in psychology to use idiographic methods to contribute to our understanding of nomothetic principles. These different research approaches can complement each other, providing a more comprehensive view of psychological phenomena.
OPERATIONALISING FREUD’S KEY TERMS
One of the significant challenges with Freud's psychodynamic theories is the difficulty in operationalizing and measuring many of the concepts he introduced. Concepts like the id, ego, superego, unconscious processes, and ego defence mechanisms are abstract and not easily quantifiable. This lack of measurability makes it challenging to subject these concepts to empirical testing using the scientific methods typically employed in psychology.
In modern psychology, there is an emphasis on operationalising variables and using quantitative methods to test hypotheses and theories rigorously. Freud's theories, while influential in shaping the field of psychology, do not always align with these empirical and measurable standards. This has led to criticism and debate within the field regarding the scientific validity of his work.
FALSIFICATION ISSUES
Karl Popper's critique of Freud's theories, particularly in the context of scientific falsifiability, is indeed a significant aspect of the debate surrounding psychoanalysis. Popper argued that for a theory to be considered scientific, it must be falsifiable, meaning that there should be a way to test it rigorously and potentially prove it wrong. According to Popper, Freud's psychoanalytic theories lacked this essential criterion because they could be interpreted so that they would always appear to be confirmed, regardless of the data.
HERE IS A SCENARIO TO ILLUSTRATE THIS POINT
Pete has battled depression for two decades, seeking the assistance of a psychoanalytic therapist without improvement. He feels worse than ever and accuses his therapist of deception, asserting that there is nothing hidden in his unconscious. Pete dismisses the theory as psychobabble, citing his happy childhood as evidence.
The therapist, in contrast, disagrees and contends that the root cause of Pete's depression is so deeply buried in his unconscious mind that it eludes conscious awareness. Pete dismisses this notion as nonsense, and a debate ensues. The question arises: can Pete provide evidence to disprove the therapist's claim?
According to Popper's criterion, for a theory to be considered scientific, it must have the potential to be proven wrong or falsified. In this scenario, Pete challenges the therapist to produce evidence that substantiates the existence of these deeply buried, painful experiences within his unconscious mind. If Pete can demonstrate the absence of such evidence, he would argue that psychoanalysis lacks falsifiability and, therefore, does not meet the criteria for scientific status.
Popper drew a sharp distinction between theories like Einstein's theory of relativity, which could make precise predictions that could be empirically tested and either verified or refuted through experimentation and Freud's psychoanalysis, which relied on interpreting past experiences. Popper's critique centred on the retrospective and subjective nature of psychoanalysis, where past events and experiences could be reinterpreted to fit the theory.
To illustrate this issue further, consider the following example: Freud's psychoanalytic framework could offer explanations for an individual's sexual inhibition based on two contradictory scenarios. On one hand, it could attribute the inhibition to insufficient affection during childhood, while on the other hand, it could attribute it to excessive affection during childhood. This apparent flexibility within Freud's framework made it exceedingly challenging to subject his theories to empirical testing in a manner that could potentially disprove them. This adaptability allowed Freud to interpret data in ways that supported his theories, rather than subjecting them to rigorous empirical scrutiny.
RECENT ADVANCES IN COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY
Cognitive psychology has made significant strides in identifying unconscious processes, including procedural memory (Tulving, 1972), automatic processing (Bargh & Chartrand, 1999; Stroop, 1935), and social psychology has highlighted the importance of implicit processing (Greenwald & Banaji, 1995). These empirical findings have underscored the significance of unconscious processes in shaping human behaviour.
Kline (1989) has argued that psychodynamic theory consists of a series of hypotheses, some of which are more amenable to testing than others, and some with more robust supporting evidence than others. While it is true that certain aspects of psychodynamic theories may not lend themselves easily to empirical testing, this does not diminish their explanatory power or preclude the possibility of testing them in the future. The evolving landscape of psychology may provide opportunities for further exploration and verification of psychodynamic concepts as our methodologies and understanding continue to advance.
HOMOPHOBIA?
Freud's theories, particularly the phallic stage and the Oedipus conflict have faced criticism for their potential to perpetuate homophobic ideas. It was theorized that males who could not successfully identify with their fathers might develop homosexual orientations, implying that homosexuality could be attributed to a fixation. However, this perspective has been widely discredited, as it does not align with contemporary understandings of human sexuality.
Furthermore, Freud's assertion on this matter has been proven incorrect by the countless heterosexual adult males who single-parent mothers raised. Modern understandings of sexual orientation recognize that it is not determined by early childhood experiences or the gender of one's primary caregiver. Sexual orientation is a complex and multifaceted aspect of human identity that cannot be reduced to simplistic explanations like those proposed by Freud. It's essential to approach the topic of sexual orientation with sensitivity, respect for diversity, and an understanding of the complexities involved.
PSYCHOANALYSIS
Psychoanalysis, commonly known as the talking cure, is a psychological theory and therapeutic approach developed by Sigmund Freud. The fundamental premise of this theory is to bring unconscious elements into conscious awareness. According to Freud, this process enables individuals to overcome psychological issues rooted in their unconscious mind, ultimately leading to the cessation of maladaptive behaviour.
Psychoanalysts undergo extensive training, including their own experience with psychoanalysis, to develop the necessary skills to decode the symbolic meanings embedded within patients' language, dreams, fantasies, wishes, and desires.
In summary, psychoanalysis operates on the foundational premise that individuals often remain unaware of their unconscious conflicts. Psychoanalysts serve as guides in bringing these conflicts into conscious awareness. This involves exploring the patient's personal history, replacing destructive thought patterns with more constructive ones, and ultimately helping patients confront traumatic memories in a secure therapeutic environment. As patients progress and become psychologically healthier, they actively engage in their therapeutic journey.
THERAPEUTIC APPROACH
In the context of treating mental disorders like severe depression, a psychoanalyst employs a multifaceted approach:
Establishing Trust: The patient is encouraged to lie on a couch to relax and build trust with the therapist. The therapist compensates for any inadequacies in the patient's previous relationships, fostering a warm and supportive environment.
Exploring Early Life: Over time, the therapist delves into the patient's personal history to identify potential sources of distorted perceptions and psychological issues rooted in their early life experiences. This process requires patience and is best executed through gentle questioning and exploring possibilities rather than making assertions, which could lead to mistrust.
Examining Interpersonal Relationships: As trust and rapport grow, the therapist investigates the patient's current interpersonal relationships. Psychoanalytic techniques are employed to uncover distortions within these relationships and to trace the origins of fixations. Throughout this process, the therapist must remain self-aware, monitoring their feelings and actions to ensure that the patient's perception of them is accurate and not distorted. In some cases, therapists may mimic a patient's actions to gain insight into ongoing relational issues.
In conclusion, psychoanalysis, as pioneered by Freud, utilizes techniques such as dream analysis, exploration of slips of the tongue, and deep interpersonal investigation to help patients gain insight into their unconscious conflicts and psychological struggles. Building trust, examining early life experiences, and evaluating current relationships are integral components of this therapeutic approach, ultimately aimed at promoting psychological healing and self-awareness.
THE PSYCHOANALYTIC TECHNIQUE
FREE ASSOCIATION: Patients are encouraged to openly express their thoughts, dreams, and memories without censorship, allowing for exploring the unconscious mind.
DREAM ANALYSIS: Freud believed that dreams held valuable insights into the unconscious. Therapists help patients interpret their dreams to uncover hidden meanings and unresolved conflicts.
TRANSFERENCE: This phenomenon occurs when patients transfer emotions, desires, and attitudes from past relationships onto the therapist. It provides an opportunity to explore unresolved issues from the patient's past.
RESISTANCE: Patients often resist discussing certain topics or emotions due to discomfort or fear. Identifying and addressing resistance helps reveal underlying conflicts.
INTERPRETATION: Therapists analyse patients' thoughts, behaviours, and expressions to provide interpretations that shed light on unconscious processes and conflicts.
WORKING THROUGH: This involves continuous exploration and analysis of unresolved issues and conflicts, helping patients gain insight and make positive changes.
CATHARSIS: Emotional release and expression are encouraged to relieve repressed emotions and conflicts.
ANALYTIC NEUTRALITY: Therapists maintain a non-judgmental and objective stance, creating a safe space for patients to explore their innermost thoughts and feelings.
ANALYSIS OF EGO DEFENCE MECHANISMS: Therapists help patients recognise and address defence mechanisms used to protect against anxiety and discomfort.
SELF-REFLECTION: Patients engage in self-examination and introspection to gain a deeper understanding of their thoughts and emotions.
These techniques collectively form the psychoanalytic process, aimed at uncovering unconscious conflicts, promoting self-awareness, and facilitating personal growth and healing.
FREUD'S CONCEPT OF PSYCHIC DETERMINATION AND FREE ASSOCIATION IN MORE DETAIL
Psychic Determination: Freud believed in the concept of psychic determination, suggesting that all mental processes are not freely chosen but are dictated by the unconscious mind. He proposed that free association was the key to unlocking suppressed thoughts and understanding the unconscious.
Free Association Development: Freud initially used a simple physical gesture, touching his forehead, to signal clients to reveal their current thoughts. Over time, he developed this technique into the tool it is today.
Free Association Practice: Free association allows patients to freely discuss thoughts, dreams, memories, or words without concern for coherency. Patients are encouraged to speak continuously in a stream of consciousness. Freud believed that this non-linear thinking process would reveal insights from the unconscious mind.
Purpose of Free Association: The primary goal of free association is not just to uncover hidden memories but to identify genuine thoughts and emotions. It is a technique in which psychoanalytic patients are urged to share whatever comes to mind during therapy, without self-censorship. This approach fosters self-discovery within an atmosphere of non-judgmental curiosity and acceptance.
Conflict and Defence Mechanisms: Psychoanalysis assumes that individuals often experience conflicts between their desire to learn about themselves and their conscious or unconscious fears of change and self-exposure. Defence mechanisms are employed to protect against this self-exposure.
Example of Free Association: Free association does not follow a linear thought pattern. Instead, it involves producing a seemingly random stream of words or thoughts. For instance, a person engaged in free association might spontaneously mention words like "dog," "red," "mother," and "scoot," or jump from one memory or emotion to another without a clear structure.
In summary, Freud's concept of psychic determination and the practice of free association are central to psychoanalysis. Free association allows patients to explore their thoughts and emotions freely, aiming to uncover hidden aspects of the unconscious mind and provide relief from mental distress.
DREAM ANALYSIS IN MORE DETAIL:
Sigmund Freud famously referred to dreams as "The royal road to the Unconscious," signifying their importance in uncovering buried and often avoided aspects of the human psyche. Freud believed that dreams were symbolic representations of our unconscious desires, originating from the primal and impulsive aspects of our personality known as the ID. He postulated that if our unconscious mind were to be fully exposed, it would pose harm to our conscious self, possibly triggering the Thanatos (death wish) and leading to self-destructive behaviours. Therefore, dream analysis offers a safe means of exploring our dreams and their symbolism, allowing us to grasp deeper truths about ourselves.
During dreams, the rational mind is believed to be suspended, making it possible to access the unconscious. Freud emphasized that through the analysis of dreams, one could tap into the hidden recesses of the psyche, bringing unresolved issues and conflicts to the conscious level. This process is a therapeutic tool for analysts to help patients understand their psychological struggles.
SLIPS OF THE TONGUE:
"Slips of the tongue," also known as parapraxes, occur when individuals unintentionally substitute one word for another or say something different from their intended message. Freud introduced the concept of the Freudian slip, suggesting that such linguistic errors reveal underlying sexual or aggressive urges from the unconscious mind. These slips of the tongue often manifest when individuals are tired, nervous, or not functioning at their cognitive peak. A trained psychoanalyst can recognize these slips and assist patients in interpreting their deeper meanings.
IN A NUTSHELL
PATIENTS ARE UNAWARE OF THEIR UNCONSCIOUS CONFLICT
Psychoanalysts bring their conflicts into their conscious mind
All symptoms are meaningful and are caused by the history of the patient
THE PSYCHOANALYST AIMS TO:
Build trust with the patient and learn their history
Replace their destructive consciousness with a more supportive, less destructive one
The aim is to help patients confront traumatic memories in a safe environment to understand their current difficulties.
Once the patient has become healthier the patient will take a more active role in his/her therapy.
RESEARCH
Freud's use of case studies played a pivotal role in the development of his psychodynamic theory and the stages of psychosexual development. While these case studies make it challenging to definitively validate or invalidate Freud's theories, they offer intriguing glimpses into his everyday interactions with clients and shed light on the origins of his influential understanding of the human mind.
LITTLE HANS
Little Hans, whose father was Freud's friend, Max Graf, developed a fear of horses after witnessing a traumatic accident. Freud's analysis suggested this fear was linked to the Oedipus complex and the phallic stage of psychosexual development. Freud believed the fear represented Hans's unconscious feelings towards his father and his love for his mother.
WOLF MAN
Dr. Sergeï Pankejeff, known as "Wolf Man," sought treatment due to various health issues. Freud connected his fears to castration anxiety, symbolized by dreams of wolves and childhood experiences with animals. Wolf Man also displayed religious rituals and blasphemous thoughts.
RAT MAN
Rat Man," possibly Ernst Lanzer, suffered from obsessive thoughts about harming loved ones. Freud attributed these anxieties to repressed desires, such as the wish to see unclothed women. The anxiety resulted from the clash between these repressed desires and moral conscience.
ANNA O
Anna O (Bertha Pappenheim) experienced hysteria symptoms, including paralysis, hydrophobia, and hallucinations. Breuer's "talking therapy" helped her recover. Freud and Breuer discussed her case in "Studies on Hysteria." Her symptoms were linked to traumatic experiences and repressed memories.
DR. DANIEL SCHREBER:
Schreber's "Memoirs of My Nervous Illness" detailed his fantasies during a period of mental illness. Freud suggested Schreber's delusions were rooted in religious doubts and "redeemer delusion." He linked Schreber's emasculation fantasies to repressed homosexual impulses directed towards family members.
EVALUATION AND A03 OF PSYCHOANALYSIS (TREATMENT)
LIMITED SUITABILITY FOR PSYCHOTIC DISORDERS:
One notable critique of psychoanalysis is its limited suitability for treating psychotic disorders, where individuals often experience a severe disconnection from reality. Establishing a therapeutic relationship with patients who are experiencing delusions or hallucinations can be exceedingly challenging.
Symptoms such as disordered thinking and language in psychotic patients may hinder the effective application of psychoanalytic techniques, as communication and interpretation become problematic.
CHALLENGES IN FORMING INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS:
Critics argue that building the close interpersonal relationships necessary for psychoanalysis may be difficult in cases of severe mental illness. Psychotic individuals may struggle to engage in the introspective and reflective processes required for traditional psychoanalysis.
LIMITED BENEFIT FOR SPECIFIC INDIVIDUALS:
Some critics contend that psychoanalysis primarily benefits highly intelligent and articulate individuals who can effectively communicate their problems. This perspective may exclude individuals with cognitive limitations or language barriers from accessing this form of treatment.
QUESTIONABLE EFFECTIVENESS:
Sceptics question the overall effectiveness of psychoanalysis, especially for severe mental disorders. The lack of empirical evidence supporting its efficacy for specific conditions has raised concerns among mental health professionals.
LACK OF SCIENTIFIC VALIDITY:
Critics argue that psychoanalysis lacks scientific validity due to its reliance on subjective interpretations and its limited empirical basis. The absence of measurable outcomes and objective criteria for success makes it challenging to evaluate its effectiveness.
TIME-CONSUMING AND COSTLY:
Psychoanalysis is often criticized for being a lengthy and expensive form of therapy. The need for multiple sessions per week over an extended period can be a significant barrier to access for many individuals.
EVOLVING THERAPEUTIC APPROACHES:
Contemporary psychotherapy approaches, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and medication management, have gained prominence for treating a wide range of mental health issues. These approaches often offer more structured and evidence-based interventions.
In summary, while psychoanalysis has made significant contributions to our understanding of human behaviour and the mind, it faces criticism for its limited applicability to severe mental disorders, questions about its effectiveness, and its resource-intensive nature. Modern mental health treatment options have expanded to include more diverse and empirically supported approaches, leading some to question the continued relevance of psychoanalysis in contemporary clinical practice.
UNFALSIFIABILITY OF PSYCHOANALYSIS:
Critics assert that psychoanalytic assumptions made during therapy cannot be effectively falsified. For example, if a psychoanalyst fails to uncover the dysfunctional family dynamics they believe underlie a patient's weak Ego development, they may attribute it to the trauma being too deeply buried in the unconscious mind.
It is argued that therapists might be reluctant to acknowledge that unconscious memories of discord did not surface during therapy because they never existed in the first place. This unfalsifiability means that psychodynamic therapies cannot be disproven.
FALSE MEMORY SYNDROME (FMS):
A notable example of therapists misinterpreting their analysis is the concept of False Memory Syndrome (FMS). In the 1990s, concerns arose regarding psychoanalysts potentially implanting false memories of child sexual abuse in their clients.
FMS emerged partly due to therapists' strong beliefs that childhood sexual abuse was a common root cause of various mental illnesses. Critics argue that therapists' interpretations of patients' language and dreams were flawed because they were overly invested in this belief.
CLAIMS SUPPORTING THE ARGUMENT OF FMS:
Critics cite three key claims to support the argument of False Memory Syndrome:
Experimental studies demonstrate that false memories of childhood events can be easily induced in laboratory settings.
There is a lack of scientific evidence supporting the existence of a repression mechanism in memory, which challenges the basis of repressed memories in psychoanalysis.
Surveys indicate that many therapists have a limited understanding of memory processes, and some employ inappropriate, suggestive techniques with clients to recover memories.
In summary, critics contend that the unfalsifiability of psychoanalytic assumptions and instances like False Memory Syndrome raise concerns about the validity and reliability of psychoanalytic techniques and interpretations. They argue that these issues challenge the scientific credibility of psychodynamic therapies.
FAMOUS PSYCHODYNAMIC THEORISTS
Sigmund Freud: Founder of psychoanalysis.
Alfred Adler: Known for individual psychology and the inferiority complex.
Theodor Adorno: Developed the Authoritarian Personality theory.
John Bowlby: Pioneer in attachment theory.
Erik Erikson: Coined the phrase "identity crisis" and emphasized ego psychology.
Frantz Fanon: Influential in post-colonial studies and critical theory.
Oliver James: Author of "They Fu*k You Up."
Carl Jung: Founder of analytical psychology and introduced concepts like the collective unconscious.
S. H. Foulkes: Focused on group analysis.
Erich Fromm: Emphasized cultural determinants of personality.
Frieda Fromm-Reichmann: Pioneer in schizophrenia treatment.
Karen Horney: Introduced the concept of womb envy.
Melanie Klein: First psychologist to view children's play as meaningful.
R. D. Laing: Known for his views on psychosis and anti-psychiatry.
Susie Orbach: Author of "Fat is a Feminist Issue."
Otto Rank: Prolific writer on psychoanalytic themes.
Wilhelm Reich: Focused on overall character structure.
Harry Stack Sullivan: Emphasized interpersonal relationships in psychiatry
ESSAY PLAN
I. Introduction A. Introduce Sigmund Freud's unique perspective on the human mind. B. Mention the division of the mind into three parts: conscious, pre-conscious, and unconscious. C. Highlight the development of the Tripartite Personality (the Id, Ego, and Superego) from birth to age six.
II. The Tripartite Personality A. Define the components of Id, Ego, and Superego. 1. Id: Describe it as the part focused on immediate desires and gratification residing in the unconscious. 2. Ego: Explain it as the conscious mediator between Id and Superego, responsible for decision-making. 3. Superego: Describe it as the moral aspect representing societal norms and values.
III. Interplay Between Components A. Discuss the importance of balance achieved through successful Ego mediation. B. Explain how conflicts during psychosexual development can lead to imbalances. 1. Id Dominance: Describe the consequences, including antisocial behaviour or addiction. 2. Superego Dominance: Discuss outcomes like anxiety or phobias. C. Emphasize the role of Ego defence mechanisms when the balance is disrupted.
IV. Ego Defense Mechanisms A. Define Ego defence mechanisms as strategies to protect against anxiety from unacceptable thoughts or feelings. B. Provide examples of common defence mechanisms (e.g., repression, denial, projection). C. Explain their role in coping with conflicts arising from Id and Superego demands.
V. Psychoanalysis Perspective A. Highlight the psychoanalytic view that unconscious, repressed instinctual drives (e.g., sex and aggression) and early negative childhood experiences contribute to individual problems. B. Conclude by stressing the significance of the Tripartite Personality in shaping an individual's psychological makeup.
VI. Conclusion A. Summarize key points discussed in the essay. B. Reiterate Freud's enduring impact on psychology through the concept of the Tripartite Personality. C. Conclude with a final thought on the ongoing relevance of Freud's ideas in understanding human behaviour.